TLPC is honored to share the important work our clinic has been doing to help improve access to communications for Americans who are deaf or hard of hearing.
In May 2024, a TLPC team led by student attorneys Sebastian Blitt, Madeline Finlayson, Sarah Misché, Kevin Nguyen, and Sophie Pickering filed a petition calling on the FCC to re-evaluate its approach to the use of automated speech recognition (ASR) to generate captions for phone calls. ASR allows services like Apple’s Siri or Amazon’s Alexa to recognize a user’s voice and transcribe it to text, but as users of these technologies know, they often make mistakes.
In 2018, the FCC authorized providers of Internet Protocol Caption Telephone Services (IP CTS) to rely exclusively on ASR to caption telephone calls for persons who are deaf and hard of hearing. Our petition, on behalf of three advocacy groups—TDIforAccess, the National Association of the Deaf, and the Hearing Loss Association of America—urges the FCC to change course and provide IP CTS users with the ability to seek human assistance when ASR malfunctions.
Although ASR technology is improving, the petition prepared by TLPC highlights how ASR performs poorly in recognizing the speech of persons with non-standard accents and speech patterns. Such individuals tend to be on the margins of American society and are more likely than most to live and work in noisy environments—which further degrades the performance of ASR. To meet the legal requirement of functional equivalence, the TLPC petition urges the FCC to require IP CTS providers to make a human communication assistant available whenever one is needed to communicate effectively.
Following a public comment period launched by the FCC in August, last month TLPC student attorneys Sarah Baldwin, Zoe Leonore Glepa, and Victor Laudano spearheaded the submission of a reply comment to the FCC. The reply comment highlighted how the proposed rule would drive innovation in the IP CTS marketplace and help the FCC develop performance metrics for these services—which it has failed to do for nearly a decade.
The full text of the petition and the reply comments prepared by TLPC on behalf of its clients are available below. We look forward to the FCC’s decision on our petition in the coming months.